10 Best Restaurants in Key West That You Need to Visit

Key West, the southernmost point in the United States, has gained a great reputation as a culinary hotspot. Known for its breathtaking sunsets, lively arts scene, and rich history, the island also has a thriving food culture that attracts visitors worldwide. According to a 2023 report by TripAdvisor, Key West ranks among the top 10 U.S. cities for food lovers, drawing over 2.5 million tourists annually. This small island offers a gastronomic experience that rivals much larger cities.

The culinary landscape in Key West is as diverse as its history. The island features a variety of cuisines, from fresh, locally caught seafood to authentic Cuban dishes, reflecting its proximity to Cuba and the influence of its population. Key lime pies are a must-try dessert, popular among locals and tourists. Visitors can enjoy everything from casual beachside eateries to upscale fine dining establishments, each offering a unique taste of the island. Classic dishes are also a highlight, combining familiar flavors with modern culinary techniques to appeal to comfort food lovers and fine dining enthusiasts.

In this blog, we will show you the best dining experiences Key West offers. We have curated a list of the top 10 restaurants that stand out for their exceptional food, ambiance, and customer service. Whether you are a seafood aficionado, a lover of Caribbean flavors, or someone seeking a fine dining experience, this guide will help you find the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings in Key West.

1. Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven offers a laid-back, eclectic atmosphere that captures the island’s charm. Located in the historic Bahama Village, the restaurant features outdoor seating under a canopy of trees, with roosters and cats roaming freely, adding to its unique character. The rustic décor, with its colorful murals and string lights, creates a casual and vibrant dining experience.

Blue Heaven Signature Dishes

Blue Heaven is renowned for its diverse menu, which showcases fresh, local seafood and ingredients. Their menu features freshly caught fish, emphasizing the quality and freshness of their seafood offerings. Signature dishes include:

• Lobster Benedict: A breakfast favorite, featuring succulent lobster, perfectly poached eggs, and a rich hollandaise sauce.
• Caribbean Jerk Chicken: A dinner staple, offering tender chicken marinated in a spicy jerk seasoning and served with rice and beans.
• Mile-High Key Lime Pie: A dessert classic famous for its towering meringue and tangy, creamy filling.

Blue Heaven Customer Reviews

Blue Heaven consistently receives high praise from both locals and tourists. As of 2024, it holds a 4.5-star rating on TripAdvisor with over 10,000 reviews. Customers frequently commend the friendly service, unique atmosphere, and delicious food. Many reviews highlight the Lobster Benedict and Key Lime Pie as must-try items.

Blue Heaven Location and Contact Information

• Address: 729 Thomas St, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 296-8666
• Website: www.blueheavenkw.com

2. Santiago’s Bodega

Santiago’s Bodega is celebrated for its extensive and diverse menu of tapas and small plates. This restaurant blends Mediterranean and Latin flavors, offering a unique dining experience where sharing dishes is encouraged. The cozy, intimate setting makes it perfect for casual meals and special occasions.

Santiago’s Bodega Chef Recommendations

• Beef Tenderloin: Served with blue cheese butter and crispy onions, this dish is a customer favorite for its tenderness and flavor.
• Lamb Lollipops: Marinated and grilled to perfection, these lamb lollipops are served with a mint chimichurri sauce.
• Stuffed Dates: Bacon-wrapped dates stuffed with goat cheese, a perfect blend of sweet and savory.
• Patatas Bravas: Crispy potatoes served with a spicy tomato sauce and aioli, a traditional Spanish tapa.
• Yellowfin Tuna Ceviche: Fresh tuna marinated in citrus juices, served with avocado and wonton crisps, recommended by the chef for its freshness and balance of flavors.

Santiago’s Bodega Customer Feedback

Santiago’s Bodega maintains a high rating of 4.7 stars on Google Reviews as of 2024, with over 5,000 reviews. Customers often praise the warm, inviting ambiance, highlighted by the rustic decor and soft lighting. The friendly and attentive staff contribute to a pleasant dining experience. Guests frequently mention the variety and quality of the tapas, noting the stuffed dates and lamb lollipops as standout dishes.

Santiago’s Bodega Location and Contact Information

• Address: 207 Petronia Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 296-7691
• Website: Santiago’s Bodega

3. Louie’s Backyard

Louie’s Backyard offers an enchanting dining experience with its beautiful oceanfront location. The restaurant features indoor and outdoor seating, with the deck providing stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. The ambiance is elegant yet relaxed, perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. The lush garden setting and gentle sea breeze add to the restaurant’s charm.

Louie’s Backyard Specialties

Louie’s Backyard is known for its innovative Caribbean-American cuisine, with fresh, local seafood as a key component of its menu. Popular dishes include:

• Conch Fritters: A classic Key West appetizer, served with a tangy dipping sauce.
• Louie’s Backyard also offers a delicious Fish Sandwich, known for its freshness and unique preparation.
• Yellowtail Snapper in Thai Curry Sauce: Fresh snapper fillet cooked to perfection, served with a fragrant Thai curry sauce and jasmine rice.
• Butter-Poached Lobster: Succulent lobster poached in butter, served with mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables.
• Coconut-Encrusted Grouper: Grouper fillet with a crispy coconut crust, paired with a mango salsa.
• Key Lime Pie: A local favorite, known for its creamy texture and tart flavor, a perfect ending to a meal.

Louie’s Backyard Customer Feedback

Louie’s Backyard consistently garners excellent reviews, with a 4.6-star rating on Yelp and over 3,000 reviews as of 2024. Customers frequently mention the breathtaking ocean views, romantic setting, and attentive service. The restaurant is praised for its sophisticated yet approachable menu, with many guests highlighting the yellowtail snapper and key lime pie as must-try items.

Louie’s Backyard Location and Contact Information

• Address: 700 Waddell Avenue, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 294-1061
• Website: Louie’s Backyard

4. Latitudes

Latitudes offers a unique dining experience on the private island of Sunset Key, accessible via a short ferry ride from the Ocean Key Resort. The restaurant’s beachfront setting provides breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico, especially during sunset. The elegant, open-air dining area, adorned with palm trees and soft lighting, creates a serene and luxurious atmosphere perfect for romantic dinners and special celebrations.

Latitudes Signature Menu Items

Latitudes focuses on fresh, island-inspired cuisine with an emphasis on seafood and locally sourced ingredients. Some of the standout dishes include:

• Caribbean Lobster Ravioli: House-made ravioli stuffed with lobster and served with a rich bisque.
• Yellowfin Tuna Tartare: Fresh tuna mixed with avocado, mango, and a spicy aioli, served with crispy wonton chips.
• Sunset Key Snapper: Local snapper pan-seared and served with coconut jasmine rice and a tropical fruit salsa.
• Filet Mignon: Grilled to perfection, served with truffle mashed potatoes and asparagus.
• Key Lime Pie: A creamy, tart pie with a graham cracker crust, highly recommended for dessert.

Latitudes also boasts an extensive wine list featuring selections from around the world, with a focus on pairing perfectly with their seafood dishes. The wine menu includes a range of whites, reds, and sparkling wines to suit every palate.

Latitudes Guest Reviews

Latitudes receives glowing reviews from diners, holding a 4.8-star rating on OpenTable with over 7,000 reviews as of 2024. Guests frequently praise the restaurant for its exceptional service, exquisite food, and stunning views. Many reviews highlight the unique experience of taking a ferry to the restaurant and dining on a private island as a highlight of their trip to Key West. The sunset views and romantic setting are often mentioned as key aspects of the dining experience.

Latitudes Location and Contact Information

• Address: 245 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040 (Ferry to Sunset Key from the Opal Key Resort & Marina)
• Phone: (305) 292-5394
• Website: Latitudes

5. The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. combines traditional American comfort food with innovative Caribbean influences. This fusion creates a menu that is both familiar and exciting, appealing to a wide array of palates. The restaurant emphasizes fresh, local ingredients and inventive cooking techniques to deliver memorable dishes.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.Popular Menu Items

• Pan-Seared Scallops: Locally sourced scallops pan-seared to perfection, served with a lemon-butter sauce. Chef Chris Shultz emphasizes the freshness and simplicity of this dish, allowing the natural flavors to shine.
• Grilled Watermelon and Shrimp Salad: A unique blend of grilled watermelon, shrimp, feta cheese, and mixed greens, topped with a balsamic reduction. This dish exemplifies the restaurant’s innovative approach to combining sweet and savory flavors. It features Key West pink shrimp, known for their sweet flavor and local significance.
• Lobster Mac & Cheese: A rich, creamy macaroni and cheese dish loaded with succulent lobster chunks. This customer favorite is praised for its decadent and comforting flavors.
• Filet Mignon with Chimichurri: A tender filet mignon grilled to perfection and topped with a vibrant chimichurri sauce. Chef Shultz highlights the quality of the meat and the bold flavors of the sauce.
• Warm Banana Bread with Ice Cream: A house-made banana bread served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, offering a delightful and comforting end to the meal.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. combines traditional American comfort food with innovative Caribbean influences, highlighting local seafood as a key component of their menu.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. Reviews

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. provides an intimate dining atmosphere. The decor features local art and colorful accents, creating a warm and inviting space. The restaurant has a 4.5-star rating on Yelp with over 1,500 reviews as of 2024. Guests often commend the friendly, attentive service and the creative, flavorful dishes. Reviews frequently mention the Lobster Mac & Cheese and the Grilled Watermelon and Shrimp Salad as standout dishes. The intimate setting and unique menu contribute to a memorable dining experience.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. Location and Contact Information

• Address: 1100 Packer Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 295-7970
• Website: The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

6. A&B Lobster House

Established in 1947, A&B Lobster House is a historic landmark in Key West renowned for its fresh local seafood and timeless dining experience. Located in the A&B Marina, this classic seafood restaurant exudes old-world charm with its elegant decor, dark wood furnishings, nautical accents, and panoramic harbor views. The atmosphere is refined and welcoming, making it a favorite for special occasions and romantic dinners.

A&B Lobster House Menu Highlights

A&B Lobster House is renowned for its fresh seafood and premium steaks, which are prepared with a focus on quality and tradition. Their menu highlights include:

• Lobster Thermidor: A decadent dish featuring lobster meat baked in a creamy sauce, topped with cheese, and served in the shell.
• Filet Mignon: A tender and juicy cut of beef, grilled to perfection and served with a choice of sauces.
• Seafood Platter: A bountiful assortment of the freshest seafood, including lobster tail, shrimp, scallops, and fish, served with drawn butter and cocktail sauce.
• Oysters Rockefeller: Fresh oysters topped with spinach, bacon, and hollandaise sauce, then baked to a golden brown.
• Key Lime Pie: A traditional dessert made with fresh key lime juice and a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream.

A&B Lobster House Customer Testimonials

A&B Lobster House maintains a high rating on review platforms, with a 4.6-star rating on TripAdvisor and over 2,000 reviews as of 2024. Customers frequently praise the impeccable service, classic ambiance, and exquisite food. Reviews often highlight the Lobster Thermidor and Seafood Platter as standout dishes. The restaurant’s scenic views of the marina and elegant setting are also mentioned as key aspects that enhance the dining experience.

A&B Lobster House Location and Contact Information

• Address: 700 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 294-5880
• Website: A&B Lobster House

7. El Siboney Restaurant

El Siboney Restaurant is an authentic Cuban dining spot in Key West, renowned for its focus on Cuban food, which has become popular among both locals and tourists. Since its establishment, it has become a beloved spot for its hearty portions, reasonable prices, and genuine Cuban flavors. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere makes it an inviting place for all diners.

El Siboney Chef Recommendations

El Siboney offers a variety of traditional Cuban dishes that are rich in flavor and prepared with care. Some of the standout items on the menu include:

• Ropa Vieja: Shredded beef slow-cooked with tomatoes, bell peppers, onions, and spices. This dish is a staple of Cuban cuisine and a customer favorite.
• Lechón Asado: Tender roast pork marinated in a tangy mojo sauce, served with black beans, rice, and sweet plantains. Chef recommends this dish for its authentic taste and tenderness.
• Vaca Frita: Crispy shredded beef sautéed with onions and lime. Known for its robust flavor and crisp texture.
• Cuban Sandwich: A classic sandwich with roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard pressed between Cuban bread.
• Paella Valenciana: A traditional Spanish dish with a Cuban twist, featuring a mix of seafood, chicken, and Spanish sausage cooked with saffron rice.
• Flan: A creamy caramel custard dessert, perfect for ending your meal on a sweet note.

El Siboney Customer Reviews

El Siboney Restaurant enjoys high ratings on review sites, boasting a 4.5-star rating on TripAdvisor with over 3,500 reviews as of 2024. Customers frequently praise the restaurant for its authentic food, generous portions, and friendly service. The atmosphere is often cozy and unpretentious, with a lively, welcoming vibe reflecting Cuban culture. Many reviewers highlight the Ropa Vieja and Lechón Asado as must-try dishes, and the Cuban Sandwich is often cited as one of the best in Key West.

El Siboney Location and Contact Information

• Address: 900 Catherine Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 296-4184
• Website: El Siboney Restaurant

8. Nine One Five

Nine One Five offers a unique dining experience with its eclectic menu that blends international flavors and contemporary culinary techniques. Housed in a beautifully restored Victorian home on Duval Street, the restaurant exudes a charming yet modern ambiance. The indoor dining rooms are elegantly decorated, while the outdoor patio provides a more casual and relaxed atmosphere under the stars.

Nine One Five Chef’s Specialties and Popular Dishes

The menu at Nine One Five is diverse, with a range of dishes that showcase the chef’s creativity and dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients. Some of the standout items include:

• Tuna Dome: A signature dish featuring seared tuna wrapped around avocado and crab salad, drizzled with a wasabi aioli and soy reduction. The presentation is as impressive as the flavors.
• Scallop Risotto: Creamy risotto cooked to perfection with large, succulent scallops, asparagus, and Parmesan cheese. The dish is rich and satisfying, highly recommended by the chef.
• Duck Confit: A tender duck leg confit served with a sweet potato purée and seasonal vegetables, showcasing a perfect balance of flavors and textures.
• Lobster Ravioli: House-made ravioli stuffed with fresh lobster meat, served in a creamy tomato and basil sauce.
• Key Lime Panna Cotta: A unique twist on the traditional Key Lime Pie, this panna cotta offers a creamy, tangy dessert that’s light and refreshing.

Nine One Five Customer Feedback and Atmosphere

Nine One Five maintains a strong reputation among diners, holding a 4.6-star rating on Yelp and Google Reviews with over 2,000 reviews as of 2024. Customers often praise the innovative menu, exceptional service, and charming setting. Many reviews highlight the Tuna Dome and Scallop Risotto as must-try dishes. The relaxed yet sophisticated ambiance, whether dining inside the historic home or outside on the patio, adds to the overall dining experience, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors.

Nine One Five Location and Contact Information

• Address: 915 Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 296-0669
• Website: Nine One Five

9. Garbo’s Grill

Garbo’s Grill offers casual dining and gourmet flavors, all served from a charming food truck. Known as a popular fish wagon, Garbo’s Grill is celebrated for its casual atmosphere and unique menu options. Located in a vibrant outdoor setting, Garbo’s Grill provides a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere perfect for enjoying delicious food in a casual environment. The food truck is stationed at Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon, allowing guests to pair their meals with a refreshing drink from the bar.

Garbo’s Grill Notable Menu Items and Customer Favorites

Garbo’s Grill is renowned for its inventive and flavorful menu items, combining high-quality ingredients with creative culinary techniques. Some of the most popular dishes include:

• Korean BBQ Tacos: Tender marinated beef topped with Asian slaw and sriracha, served on soft corn tortillas. This dish is a customer favorite for its bold flavors and perfect balance of sweet and spicy.
• Umami Burger: A gourmet burger featuring a juicy beef patty, Swiss cheese, caramelized onions, and umami sauce, served on a toasted bun. This burger is praised for its rich, savory taste.
• Yum Yum Shrimp Tacos: Fresh shrimp tossed in a spicy, creamy sauce, served with cabbage and cilantro in a soft tortilla. The shrimp are cooked to perfection, making this dish a standout.
• Mango Dog: A twist on the classic hot dog, topped with mango, jalapeños, and house-made sauces. It’s a refreshing and spicy take on a traditional favorite.
• Cuban Mix Sandwich: A pressed sandwich with roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard, reflecting Key West’s Cuban influences.

Garbo’s Grill Reviews

Garbo’s Grill consistently receives great reviews, holding a 4.8-star rating on Google Reviews with over 1,000 reviews as of 2024. Customers frequently praise the food for its exceptional quality and flavor, often highlighting the Korean BBQ Tacos and Umami Burger as must-try items. The food truck ambiance is casual and fun, with outdoor seating encouraging socializing and enjoying the Key West weather. The partnership with Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon adds to the lively atmosphere, making it a popular spot for both locals and tourists.

Garbo’s Grill Location and Contact Information

• Address: 409 Caroline Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 304-3004
• Website: Garbo’s Grill

10. Café Marquesa

Café Marquesa provides an exquisite fine dining experience in the heart of Key West. Café Marquesa’s menu features a variety of innovative dishes, showcasing the chef’s creativity and dedication to fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Located in a boutique hotel, this intimate restaurant combines sophisticated elegance with a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. The décor is classic and refined, featuring soft lighting, white tablecloths, and tasteful artwork, creating a luxurious and comfortable ambiance.

Café Marquesa Signature Dishes

Café Marquesa is known for its innovative American cuisine, focusing on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The menu changes seasonally to incorporate what is available, ensuring a fresh and exciting dining experience. Some of the signature dishes include:

• Seared Sea Scallops: Perfectly seared scallops served with a cauliflower purée, roasted Brussels sprouts, and a citrus beurre blanc. This dish highlights the chef’s skill in balancing flavors and textures.
• Lamb Shank: Braised lamb shank served with creamy polenta, roasted root vegetables, and a red wine reduction. The tender meat and rich sauce make it a standout item.
• Yellowtail Snapper: Locally caught snapper, pan-seared and served with a lemon caper butter sauce, accompanied by sautéed spinach and fingerling potatoes.
• Duck Breast: Pan-roasted duck breast with a cherry gastrique, served with wild rice and seasonal vegetables. This dish is known for its succulent meat and flavorful sauce.
• Key Lime Cheesecake: A twist on the classic Key lime pie, this cheesecake is smooth and tangy, served with a graham cracker crust and fresh berries.

Café Marquesa Customer Reviews

Café Marquesa enjoys high praise from diners, with a 4.7-star rating on TripAdvisor and over 1,500 reviews as of 2024. Customers often commend the exceptional service, refined ambiance, and beautifully presented dishes. Many reviews highlight the Seared Sea Scallops and Lamb Shank as must-try items. The intimate setting and attentive staff contribute to a dining experience that is both special and memorable, making it a top choice for fine dining in Key West.

Café Marquesa Location and Contact Information

• Address: 600 Fleming Street, Key West, FL 33040
• Phone: (305) 292-1244
• Website: Café Marquesa

Key West Restaurants – Summary

Key West has a vibrant and diverse culinary scene that offers something for every palate. From the eclectic ambiance of Blue Heaven to the fine dining elegance of Café Marquesa, these top 10 Key West restaurants highlight the island’s best dining experiences. Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen, located inside the Perry Hotel and Marina on Stock Island, is another premier dining destination known for its seafood-centric menu and fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

Whether you’re a fan of fresh seafood, authentic Cuban cuisine, or innovative tapas, Key West’s culinary landscape will not disappoint. Each restaurant provides a unique atmosphere and menu, ensuring a memorable meal regardless of your choice.

We encourage you to explore these dining gems and share your experiences. Your feedback can help others discover the rich flavors and exceptional service that make Key West a top culinary destination. Additionally, keep an eye out for food festivals and culinary events in Key West, such as the Key West Food & Wine Festival and the Lobsterfest. These events are excellent opportunities to sample a wide variety of dishes and celebrate the island’s food culture.